Does a transparency flag mean a GIF has transparent pixels? No. Our controlled example flags an unused palette index while every decoded raster pixel stays opaque. We made two original synthetic files. Each is one thousand nine hundred thirteen bytes. Both have four full ninety six by fifty six frames, the same palette, compressed image payloads, delays, disposal and looping. The source raster only uses indices zero through three. One file disables transparency. The other flags index two hundred fifty five in every frame, without using that index. Four local runs of the engine deployed by SlimGIF produce five hundred eighty byte files. These are local executions, not observed website downloads. Equal sizes do not mean equal bytes. The flagged input's output keeps the first frame flag on, changes its transparent index byte to four, and turns off the other three flags. The opaque control output keeps all flags off. The first flagged output index is not represented by one of the four RGB table entries. We report this unused designation and the observed decoder result, without promising that every application interprets it identically. For each setting the two outputs differ in three bytes: background index at offset eleven, first frame packed control at forty seven, and transparent index at fifty. Within each input, the lossless setting and default setting outputs are byte identical. Pillow and FFmpeg independently decode all six files to matching complete R G B A frames. Every raster pixel has alpha two hundred fifty five. There are five thousand three hundred seventy six pixels per frame, or twenty one thousand five hundred four across the animation. Stored delays, dimensions and looping also match in our local checks. The transparency flag does not by itself prove the existence of a transparent hole. Nor does clearing a flag save a whole byte in these fixed size control blocks. The total encoder reduction also involves palette and frame representation changes. We deliberately start with opaque artwork. This is not a test of white halos, real transparent backgrounds or disposal trails. No subjective quality, current browser rendering or real time playback measurement was made. Download the original files, hashes, commands and code at SlimGIF dot com slash gif unused transparency flag. Original synthetic figures are C C zero, and this English narration is synthesized.